Wednesday 19. January 2022
COMECE Press 21.10.2004


12 recommendations for a fair and consistent EU Migration and Asylum Policy


Six Christian organisations will present 12 recommendations for a fair and consistent EU Migration and Asylum Policy to the Ministers of the Justice and Home Affairs Council in Luxembourg from 25-26 October 2004.


The six organisations – Caritas Europa, the Churches’ Commission for Migrants in Europe

(CCME), the Secretariat of the Commission of Bishops’ Conferences of the European

Community (COMECE), the International Catholic Migration Commission, the Jesuit

Refugee Service Europe (JRS) and the Quaker Council for European Affairs - argue that the 12 recommendations should be incorporated into EU asylum and migration policy in order to protect the human rights of migrants and refugees.


The six organisations recommend that EU Migration and Asylum policy should provide a framework for the regularisation of irregular migrants, the recognition of family reunification as a fundamental right, a common approach to integration policy, and a modified return and readmission policy. They urge the member states to ratify the international convention on migrants’ rights adopted in the United Nations in 1990. Combating trafficking in human beings should constitute a specific policy and also seek to offer long-term perspectives to the victims. A common and coherent asylum system must guarantee high standards for refugees. Asylum seekers and refugees should have access to a full asylum determination procedure, which should be in compliance with the rule of law. Refugees should be guaranteed a protected status during their asylum application and be admitted access to the labour market.


The organisations call upon the Ministers as they prepare the next multi-annual programme in Justice and Home Affairs, to seriously consider these 12 recommendations. They are based upon the inalienable dignity of human beings. They aim to highlight the economic, social and cultural benefits of migration for society. Security threats must not contravene the crucial principle which underpins this policy area.






  1. Migration and Asylum policy must respect the inalienable dignity of each human being and thus respect human rights. Security concerns have to uphold these crucial principles and may not undermine these principles. The economic, social and cultural benefits of migration for the societies need to be recognised.
  2. A close monitoring of the transposition of Community Law into national legislation is essential to ensure consistent and correct application. At the same time, we urge the Member States to ratify the International Convention on the Rights of all Migrant Workers and the Members of their Families.
  3. The targets of the Nice Treaty and the Constitutional Treaty should be introduced as quickly as possible in order to achieve the co-decision procedure and qualified majority voting in the Council of Ministers.




4. The reality of irregular migration should be fully acknowledged, while developing a labour migration policy. This requires an approach that takes into account the demand on the EU labour market for qualified as well as unqualified labour force. Regularisation schemes for irregular migrants should be seen as a means to improve both the individual situation of the irregular migrant and should be considered as one response to the demands of the labour market. EU legislation should not criminalize migrants in irregular situations.


5. The right to family reunification is a fundamental right. Thus it should be protected and supported. It should not be labelled as an instrument of immigration management. Moreover, family life is a very important element for the integration of migrants in European society.


6. The EU needs a common approach to integration policy that promotes integration as a reciprocal process, with an active role for migrants as well as for the receiving society, resulting in an inclusive and welcoming society. The increasing diversity in our society should be actively promoted as a positive factor, thus also promoting a better public understanding of migration and asylum matters.


7. A common policy on return and readmission needs to uphold the dignity of the person and provide perspectives for the migrants. Thus there should be no forced return after 5 years of legal stay in the host country. To support voluntary return to the home country, coherent reintegration schemes need to be established. Readmission to a third country is only acceptable if strong personal links to that country exist or the person requests this as an alternative. Any return policy has to safeguard family unity and particularly children’s rights. Detention of irregular migrants and asylum seekers should be avoided.


8. Combating Trafficking in human beings should constitute a specific policy area in itself. Victims of trafficking should be offered safe solutions and long-term perspectives in order to enable them to live a self-sufficient life independently of their willingness to testify against the traffickers in court. In order to gather a comprehensive knowledge of the phenomenon more resources should be invested in research and collection of data; cooperation between relevant authorities and civil society organisations should be enhanced.


9. Humanitarian assistance to irregular migrants provided by Churches, Christian organisations and NGOs should be protected from unjust prosecution.




10. A European fundamental right to asylum and subsidiary protection should be laid down as soon as possible by the ratification of the Constitutional Treaty. Existing international law on the protection of refugees must be fully and correctly applied in order to achieve high standards in a common asylum system and, in particular, ensure a high level of protection for refugees in accordance with the rules of international law.


11. The asylum procedures need to provide for full access of persons to an asylum determination procedure, with free legal and interpretation services and the possibilities for appeal with suspensive effect. Accelerated procedures without access to information and legal assistance, and the «safe third country» concept undermine the rule of law. The explicit right of all asylum seekers to remain in the asylum country pending a final decision (effective remedy) should be laid down in EU legislation.


12. The objective of all asylum policy and of other instruments for refugee protection should be to find durable solutions for refugees. Asylum applications should be processed within 12 months; all asylum seekers should have access to the labour market after the shortest possible time. Refugees and persons granted a complementary protection status should be allowed to move in the EU without restrictions. The duration of temporary protection status should be limited to 2 years maximum.


The signatory organisations represent churches throughout Europe - Anglican, Orthodox, Protestant and Roman Catholic - as well as Christian organisations particularly concerned with migrants and refugees. As Christian organisations, we are deeply committed to the dignity of the human individual created in the image of God, the concept of global solidarity and the idea of a society welcoming strangers.

Press contact:

Alessandro Di Maio

Press & Communications Manager E-mail contact Tel.: +32 (0) 2 235 05 15
Contact us
19, Square de Meeûs
B-1050 Bruxelles
T + 32(0)2 235 05 10