Press Release

🔴 DOCUMENT | Erasure from baptismal registers at the EU Court: COMECE issues new Position Paper

Click here to open the Position Paper.

On Friday, 20 November 2026, the Commission of the Bishops’ Conferences of the European Union (COMECE) published a Position Paper providing detailed technical comments on the Opinion delivered by the Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union in Case C-12/25, Bisdom Gent. Download Position Paper [EN]

Prepared with the support of the COMECE Legal Affairs Commission, the document focuses on aspects of the Opinion that give rise to concern, putting forward key elements that may support an alternative interpretation of the case and, consequently, lead to different conclusions.

Considering the potential impact of the proceedings on the delicate balance of Church-State relations at national level, COMECE hopes that the EU Court’s final ruling will provide indications ensuring the full protection of baptismal registers against erasure.

The main elements of the COMECE Position Paper are outlined below.

Registers of sacraments vs Registers of members
The Opinion is based on the premise that baptismal registers are relevant for defining the membership of a religious community. COMECE underlines that baptismal registers do not record present membership, but rather document a historical and sacramental fact.

Necessity of processing baptismal data
According to COMECE, the Opinion of the Advocate General bases its assessment of ‘necessity’ on an excessively narrow understanding of the purposes served by baptismal registers. The function of such registers is not limited to preventing the risk of a ‘second baptism’ or facilitating the administration of the sacrament. In fact, the Opinion does not take into account other uses of baptismal registers in the life of the Church, such as establishing sacramental and canonical status, supporting subsequent annotations, enabling the issuing of reliable certificates throughout a person’s life, and protecting the rights and interests of third parties.

Moreover, the fact that – as stated in the Opinion – the system of baptismal registers could theoretically be circumvented by a person concealing a previous baptism, does not mean that the system is unnecessary or inappropriate.

The Opinion refers to possible alternatives to the storage of baptism data: e.g. correspondence with the Church in view of erasure; Canon 876 on the possibility, under certain conditions, to prove the conferral of baptism through the declaration of a witness or the oath of the baptised person. However, as explained in the COMECE Position Paper (pp. 4–5), these alternatives cannot be considered sufficiently valid.

Balance of interests
Taking into account all the elements of the case, the ‘compelling legitimate grounds’ invoked by the Church should, in principle, override the interests, rights and freedoms of the data subject. In this regard, the COMECE Position Paper outlines, among others, the following arguments:

  • In the Catholic Church, baptism is the ‘gateway’ to the other sacraments. Any interference with the functioning of baptismal registers would have a negative ‘ripple effect’ on all the other sacraments, increasing the hindrance to Church activities.
  • The individual dimension of freedom of religion should be kept on an equal footing with the collective and the institutional dimension of this fundamental right.
  • In balancing the interests at stake, the Opinion attaches disproportionate weight to the lack of consent of the baptised person.
  • The baptismal record does not necessarily reveal the present beliefs, convictions or current religious affiliation of the baptised person.
  • COMECE argues against providing particular relevance to the emotional distress arising from non- Accepting this approach may have far-reaching implications for many categories of historical, educational, professional, institutional records, even for civil status registers. Furthermore, it would be hardly possible for the Church, as data controller, to assess purely subjective considerations.
  • The position paper also highlights the importance of the recently published European Data Protection Board Guidelines on processing of personal data on the basis of legitimate interest.

Archiving in the public interest and historical research purposes
COMECE underlines not only that the concept of ‘public interest’ should not be interpreted too restrictively, but also that the value of archives lies in their integrity. The Opinion adopts a too narrow concept of ‘historical research’ and unduly downplays the high relevance of baptismal registers in view of research for genealogical purposes.

Annotations in the margin
The Opinion rejects the solution of adding a marginal annotation to the baptismal record to reflect the wishes of the baptised person concerned. In this regard, the COMECE Position Paper puts forward several critical remarks:

  • The approach proposed in the Opinion may lead to an increase in data processing.
  • The parallel drawn between baptismal registers and commercial databases is highly inappropriate.
  • The name, surname and date of birth of the baptised person do not constitute excessive or ancillary data under the data minimisation principle. Removing them would deprive the records of their essential content, meaning, value and purpose.
  • The prejudicial impact of data erasure on the rights and interests of third parties should be given greater consideration.
  • The Opinion affirms that doctrinal matters are excluded from EU interference. Such principle also concerns Canon Law.
  • Resorting to practical solutions, such as opaque stickers or similar physical interventions, sits uneasily with the principles of archival authenticity, integrity and reliability that underpin the preservation of historical records across the EU.
  • The practice of annotation to the margin adopted by the Church is not meant to ‘replace’ erasure or to implement erasure. Rather, it is a legal solution introduced to address situations in which erasure is not possible under any circumstances. This impossibility stems from the fact that the data concerning the baptised person relate to an event that actually took place.

Interpreting Canon Law within the EU legal framework
In its document, COMECE underlines that EU and national courts should not interpret provisions of Canon Law in isolation from their legal and doctrinal context. They should also refrain from attributing to these provisions meanings that run counter to the authoritative interpretation adopted within the Church’s legal order. In this regard, COMECE expresses surprise at the absence of any reference in the Opinion to the Explanatory Note adopted by the Holy See’s Dicastery for Legislative Texts.

Practical impact and legal uncertainty
The approach proposed in the Opinion would lead to excessive proceduralisation, with considerable legal uncertainty for ecclesiastical data controllers, and to a likely surge in litigation. This negative impact would affect contexts already administratively limited, such as parishes. The possibility of maintaining a consistent and uniform policy within the Church would also be put at risk.

COMECE has been following Case C-12/25, Bisdom Gent, since its inception before the Court of Justice of the European Union. In September 2026, the COMECE Secretariat prepared a Position Paper to react to the hearing in the proceedings. In October 2026, following the publication of the Advocate General’s Opinion, the Secretariat issued a brief preliminary reaction.

Considering the potential impact the proceedings may have on the delicate balance of Church-State relations at the national level, COMECE hopes that the EU Court’s final ruling will provide indications ensuring full protection of baptismal registers from erasure.

Download Position Paper [EN]